This is an exact(ish) replica of the Woobles(?) crochet Pacman Ghost eyes, well as close as I could make in PLA.

In the pictures the darker blue one on the right is the actual, and the teal and glow in the dark one are the replica prints.

My wife wanted different colors than what she could buy. If printing in a different material (ABS/ASA), maybe we could post process and get the shiny rounded top layer. But this was using only support removal and using PLA, so we used a .2 nozzle and the smallest layer height we could in order to get the least visible layer lines.

ADDED: an adaptive layer height profile. adds a little strength and finishes faster.