Search models, users, collections, and posts
Recommendation
Creator’s Club
Creators & Fans
Show Your Make
Off Topic
Post Details
Reviewing a Model Correctly
Reviewing a Model Correctly

It seems that everywhere you look, you find reviews that say “Great”, "Good", “Love it”, etc…

Though they never said what was great, good, or what they loved about the model. That's what we will be covering today.

 

First, I want to start with what not to do: when you're reviewing a model, you're not reviewing how your specific print came out. Rather, how the model functions, details, and even problems that can be fixed with settings. You do not base your star rating on how your print has one droopy overhang from your support falling off. That nicely takes us to the topic of bed adhesion. When a model doesn't stick to the build plate, that is more than likely user error. You might ask, how do I fix that? It's super simple: wash your build plate with warm water and dish soap. It is best to wipe the build plate dry with a paper towel. Why not use alcohol? Alcohol will spread the natural grease from your hands around on the print surface, rather than cleaning it. Which is where the problem comes from, touching the print surface. The natural grease from your hands decreases bed adhesion. Let's get back to reviews: when you have a print failure, the designer of the model will be more than pleased if you make a comment stating your issue, rather than writing a review that says “Bad" . Then again, there is another thing done wrong. You cannot write a review just simply saying “Bad”, “Doesn't work”, “Hate it”, etc… You need to explain why the model is bad, why it didn't work, or why you hate it. If the review does not contain why, it will be removed due to it not being a valid review.

 

Second, we'll talk about what you should do in a review. Include a photo! Taking a photo of your new print is fun! Take it someplace cool and snap a quick pic; the designer will love it. The photo will need to be of the model, or it isn't a valid review. Don't just be plain and say “Nice” when you write your review; give some detail on what makes it nice. For example, “The supports came off nicely.” Look at you go! Now, think of some other things you liked about this model you printed. Maybe it's speed while printing? Say it! “The print was super fast and had great quality.” Now look what you did, more detail! You said it had great quality; now readers reading your review will know that this model has supports that remove nicely, prints fast, has great quality, and from your fun photo they can see all of that. If this model you printed is functional, say how it has helped you in whatever way it does; also talk about your favorite feature of the print as well. Maybe you should throw in an emoji here and there; why? Emojis are fun! They will help your review stand out from others as well. You can even say what filament you printed in. That way, if the reader wants to recreate your print, they can.

 

Let's put this into action: “The supports came off this model nicely. Also, it printed super fast and had great quality 🤩. Gotta love the dual jet engines as well. I decided to print in Bambu Lab Iridium Gold PLA Metal, which looks nice on my desk 😙🤌.”

Look at you! Such a professional reviewer.

(Edited)
Share
134
311
9
Comment (311)
@CanadianJedi 1 star "i dont know how to print"
The poster has replied
poster
9
Reply
@GreyWolf14 crazy.
1
Reply
@Romans1x16 Exactly haha 😂
1
Reply
@PocketArmourCO I feel like that most people dont put much effort in because they dont like spending time writing reviews i feel like all thats needed is a rating and a reason why, something that annoys me is that if a print is cancelled u cant rate it 4 or 5 stars so alot of people rate it 3 starts because they cant rate higher that should be fixed
poster
5
Reply
@Simply_Engineer i deff don't do this
0
Reply
@Simply_Engineer ummm....
0
Reply
@user_3920533768 I'm sorry, who the heck are you to tell me how to rate something? I will absolutely rate on how the print came out, that's the whole reason I look at ratings and reviews. Looking at your submitted models, I can see why you post this; get bent.
The poster has replied
5
Reply
@QuadA @Romans1x16 : 😶‍🌫️ My looking at the comment 😂
1
Reply
@user_3920533768 @Creative_User : So creative :)
0
Reply
@3DRIO I love this! you should copy the whole thing and send it to any bad reviews 🤣 they'd be so confused
The poster has replied
poster
5
Reply
@3DRIO @Romans1x16 : I just replyed
poster
1
Reply
@Romans1x16 @3DRIO : Just commented
0
Reply
@PotaterSoup7 Bad.
The poster has replied
poster
5
Reply
@PotaterSoup7 @Pr1ntCraft : 🤣🤣🤣
1
Reply
@Pr1ntCraft 😆🤣😂 you learned nothing!
0
Reply
@bMissle ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ I liked this post because it had step by step instructions 😍 It really helps me understand the correct way to rate 👍
poster
1
Reply
@blufufuf3D Now this is bow to review a model! I will literally see review like, "good." Like this would be me, "Ok. Good in what sense. Good in Bad? Good in it went well?"
The poster has replied
poster
2
Reply
@Romans1x16 @blufufuf3D : Yeah of course!
0
Reply
@blufufuf3D @Romans1x16 : Thank you!
poster
1
Reply
@Northeast3Dd this is GOLD! this is exactly what most people on this platform need! anybody that checks the hashtag “#Crazy Reviews” knows what im talking about. most people dont like reviewing well or are just haters.
The poster has replied
poster
1
Reply
@Romans1x16 I appreciate it! :)
0
Reply
@GabeTechInd "⭐️/⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ My power went out." Sorry I saw this rating before, and after seeing this post it reminded me of this LOL.
0
Reply
@QuadA Thanks for putting in the time to write this, now if only everybody on MakerWorld would read this!
The poster has replied
poster
1
Reply
@QuadA @Romans1x16 : Yeah
poster
1
Reply
@Romans1x16 It’s my peasure! That’d be great. Then they’d have to apply it to make the difference haha
0
Reply
Trend
PrintClinic
HideAndSeekChallenge
Weekly Roundup
1
the Great Benchy Nations
4.1 k
2
Questions
1.5 k
3
Theprintertribes
1.2 k
4
Newmodel
733
5
Needhelp
553
6
Contests
512
7
Face Reveal
391